I did it. I did the buggering impossible. I essentially took the forum module and the book review module and smacked them together. What do we get for it? Book reviews now come with bread crumbs (those little link paths across the top of your screen) that work, and we can view book reviews via category now, instead of just flopped in a list. Reviewers can edit their own book reviews. The code for this is HUGE, so I'm going to spend some time removing non-bookreview related material from it (such as functions for making bookreviews sticky, etc.).

Might be able to implement a "search by title" type index. Let's see how far I can go with it as is, first.

****
I live under a bridge.